Supreme Court Rules Credit Card Fees are Covered Under Free Speech

Supreme Court Rules Credit Card Fees are Covered Under Free Speech

March 30, 2017         Written By Bill Hardekopf

The U.S. Supreme Court has thrown out a 2015 lower court’s ruling that upheld a New York law, which barred retailers from charging customers more when they paid with their credit cards. SCOTUS sent the case back to a lower court, and instructed that court to hear the case on the grounds of free speech and not on price regulation.

Whenever a customer completes a transaction with a credit card, the merchant has to pay a fee to the credit card company. The New York law, which is similar to those found in nine other states, prevented retailers from charging a different price to those paying with their credit card. It also barred merchants from calling the fees paid to card companies “surcharges” while adding that surcharge to the price of the product. Retailers could still offer discounts to those paying with cash. Merchants violating the law were subject to a potential one-year prison sentence and $500 fine.

The merchants in the case were arguing the law is a violation of their free speech rights, and the unanimous ruling, which was authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, agreed. Roberts wrote that businesses “want to make clear that they are not the bad guys.” SCOTUS did not rule whether the measure is lawful.

A spokeswoman for New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman told the Associated Press, “We respect the court’s decision and will continue to defend the statute on remand” to the lower court.

The information contained within this article was accurate as of March 30, 2017. For up-to-date
information on any of the terms, cards or offers mentioned above, visit the issuer's website.


About Bill Hardekopf

Bill Hardekopf is the CEO of and covers the credit card industry from all perspectives. Bill has been involved with personal finance for over 15 years. He is a frequent contributor to Forbes, The Street and The Christian Science Monitor.
View all posts by Bill Hardekopf
Featured Low Interest Card
Top Features : 1.25X miles on every purchase; no annual fee; bonus of 20,000 miles once $1,000 is spent in first 3 months
Featured Cash Back Card
Top Features : 1.5% cash back on all purchases; $150 bonus after spending $500 in first 3 months
Featured No Annual Fee Card
Top Features : Earn cash back TWICE. 1% when you buy plus 1% as you pay; 0% APR for 18 months on balance transfers
Featured Bad Credit Card
Top Features : Perfect credit not required; Reports to major credit bureaus
Featured Fair Credit Card
Top Features : No annual fee; access to higher credit line after making first 5 monthly payments on time
Featured Limited/No Credit
Top Features : No annual fee; reports to major credit bureaus; access to higher credit line after making first 5 monthly payments on time